The rain was falling as
if someone were sharpening knives against the sky.
I
first saw the man at a quarter past eleven that night, beneath the awning of
the Atlantic Bar. He wore a dark hat, a dark raincoat, and an expression as
dark as the clothes and the night. But in this city, that didn't set him apart
from anyone.
What
caught my attention was that he had my face. Not similar features. My face. The
same broken nose from the same long-forgotten fight years ago. The same scar
beside the left ear. The same wrinkles carved by cheap whiskey, Turkish
cigarettes, and the wrong women.
He
stood staring at me from across the street. I stared back. Neither of us
crossed.
Cars
raised curtains of water between us. At times he vanished behind the
headlights, only to emerge again like a photograph developing in a darkroom. I
thought of a long-lost brother, a con man wearing a mask, a lunatic escaped
from some institution. I even thought that someone had forgotten a mirror on
the other side of the street.
The
night invited foolish thoughts... and I'm a specialist in those.
Then
the man slowly raised his right hand. I didn't move. He held up something
between his fingers. A photograph.
Even
from that distance I recognized the image. It was the dead woman I had found
that morning.
And
behind her, smiling for the camera, stood him and me. Together. Like old
friends. Like partners. Like accomplices.
"Hey!,"
I shouted, determined to break the stalemate.
"We
can skip the formalities," he replied. “Surely you realize that...”
"No!,"
I cut him off.
My
outburst sounded disproportionate. I was aware that something about the man,
the double, was flawed. Something essential escaped me. Some detail invalidated
the copy and made it impossible to accept that any of this could be real.
"Let's
accept the evidence of our senses."
It
sounded ridiculous.
I
had found Eloísa Murnau's body after tailing her for weeks at the request of
her husband, a gangster named Marco Robotti. But my double had not been there
with me.
So
why was he in the photograph?
"If
you know me that well," I managed to say, “then you know I haven't touched
a drop of alcohol in six months.”
Half
my words were carried away by the wind and rain, but that didn't stop my double
from letting out a loud laugh, celebrating the clumsiness of my reasoning. Yet
the laugh itself seemed proud of its own crudity, of my own vulgarity. I tried
to think about something else, imagining that it might drive away the mirage. The
opposite happened. Suddenly the guy was standing beside me, jabbing me sharply
in the ribs.
"Where
does this need of yours come from, this urge to turn every pattern into a
story? Doctors want a pathological explanation. Journalists want a scandal.
Readers want a solution. Cops want a killer. But nature is under no obligation
to provide narrative solutions."
I
instinctively stepped back and leaned against a peeling wall. A rat scurried
between my legs, sending such an intense shiver through me that, for a moment,
the image of my doppelgänger wavered like the flame of a candle.
But
it did not disappear. Can there exist a real, observable, predictable
phenomenon whose explanation remains inaccessible to human intelligence?
"At
the end of the day," I said aloud, trying to steady myself, “a
hallucination is a hallucination. Nothing more.”
"Of
course," said my double. “The problem is that a hallucination explains
nothing, either.”
He
lit a cigarette. The match briefly illuminated his face, and I had the
unpleasant sensation of seeing myself reflected in a photograph taken ten years
in the future.
"Hallucinations
don't know things the hallucinating person doesn't know," he added, taking
advantage of my bewilderment.
He
slipped a hand into his raincoat pocket and pulled out a small black notebook. My
black notebook. The same one that had vanished from my desk three weeks
earlier. He opened it halfway.
"Page
forty-seven," he said.
I
didn't answer. Or perhaps I did. At that point, it was impossible to tell
whether he was the one speaking or I was.
"I
don't remember..."
"You
wrote that Eloísa Murnau had been afraid of elevators since she was nine years
old because she spent three hours trapped inside one with her aunt's corpse.
You never told anyone that. Not even Robotti."
The
rain struck the cobblestones with a mechanical stubbornness that was also
somehow perverse. Could any conclusion be drawn from such relentlessness?
Perhaps rain had discovered a way to be sentimental and pragmatic at the same
time, while, like so many other things, leaving meaning outside the reach of
human understanding.
"I
could have found that out," I said, trying to crawl out of the
philosophical swamp into which I had wandered.
"Of
course you could have. But you didn't."
He
turned a few pages.
"You
also wrote that you intended to leave the city as soon as this job was over.
Montevideo. A boarding house near the harbor. Fishing now and then. No more
chasing unfaithful husbands, unfaithful wives, and mediocre murderers."
I
felt a hollow sensation in my stomach. I had never written that. I had thought
it. But I had never written it down. And that was far worse. My double closed
the notebook.
"All
right. Objective accomplished," I said. “Time for you to disappear. Fade
away.”
My
double ignored me or pretended to.
"Now
I'd like to know something, my dear partner. If I am a creation of your mind...
why am I the one who knows the secrets you're so determined to ignore? What
filthy, foul-smelling enigma are you trying to bury in the deepest basement of
your mind? You were at the motel where Eloísa Murnau was murdered. You ran like
a rat when you heard the police sirens. Yet you couldn't resist the sinister
impulse to take a photograph of yourself beside the corpse. I hope you'll
explain that to me. I'm patient."
"I
want to see the photograph again. These days images can be forged, and
I..."
I
never finished the sentence. My double was already handing me the photograph. I
took it with my left hand. The rain had softened the edges, but the image
remained perfectly visible.
There
was Eloísa Murnau. Dead. Her neck twisted at an impossible angle. The motel
lamp cast an oblique shadow across the bed. And behind her stood the two of us.
Me. And me again. My partner. My doppelgänger. My double.
I
did not hesitate to repeat the thought stubbornly, like the rain striking the
pavement, not because repetition could change anything, but because repetition
itself challenged the reason for that impossible scene. I studied the
photograph for several seconds. Then I studied it for several seconds more. Something
was definitely wrong. Not with the photograph. With my memory.
"Do
you see it?," the double asked. I didn't answer. Because I was beginning
to. The motel room had only one window. Yet the photograph showed two. One
beside the bed. The other behind us. A window I didn't remember seeing. A
window that, I was certain, had never existed. I felt something shifting slowly
inside my head. Like a heavy piece of furniture being dragged across an empty
room.
"Now
we're getting to the interesting part," said my double.
And
for the first time since he had appeared across the street, I suspected that he
wasn't trying to convince me of anything. He was trying to make me remember
something that had never happened. I slipped the photograph into my raincoat
pocket, spread the fingers of my right hand, and tapped them one by one with my
left.
"Eloísa's
corpse. Robotti. The two of us. The photograph. What's this thing that's
tickling the palm of my hand?"
"Thank
goodness we only have five fingers on each hand," he replied with a
smile." I'm afraid too much Hammett, Chandler, and Cain has rotted your
brain. Without any malice, I suggest a healthy dose of Christie and Simenon. It
might help clarify some of the dark images you've concocted. A decent photo-editing
program wouldn't hurt, either. Hard-boiled fiction"please! Sometimes it
seems you've locked yourself inside a bubble even more fantastic than science
fiction. Reality, my friend, is something simple... especially if we set aside
everything we neither understand nor ever will.
"Thank
you very much for the lesson," I said. “Are you going to help me solve
Eloísa Murnau's murder, or do you intend to keep insulting my reading habits?”
My
double appeared to ponder the question.
"Robotti
didn't hire you to find Eloísa."
"I
never said that was the gangster's intention."
"Exactly."
The
rain continued to fall between us. I could no longer remember whether I was
soaked through or whether the water was simply part of the same nightmare from
which I couldn't wake.
"Robotti
hired you to follow his wife because he suspected she had a lover. That's true.
What you never asked yourself was why Eloísa seemed so determined to be
followed."
A
small jolt ran through me. Not because the idea was brilliant. Because it was
obvious. Too obvious. I remembered Eloísa entering cafés whose windows left her
visible from the street. I remembered the taxis she hailed and abandoned a few
blocks later. I remembered her abrupt changes of route. For weeks I had
interpreted those movements as attempts to shake me off. What if she wasn't
trying to shake me off?
"No,"
I murmured.
"Yes."
"That
proves nothing."
"It
proves that she wanted someone to reconstruct a route."
My
double pointed to the pocket where I had slipped the photograph.
"And
you still haven't understood the destination of that route."
For
the first time since that impossible conversation had begun, I felt something
worse than fear. I felt curiosity.
"Where
are we?," I asked.
My
double looked at me, perhaps surprised by my sudden change of direction. I had
come to the conclusion that this was the important question. Not the what, the
how, or the when… but the where.
I
felt that I might be able to dismantle that obtuse, ramshackle structure if
only I could determine the location of the dream, delusion, hallucination, or
whatever it was that held me prisoner in such an absurd situation. And my
doppelgänger realized that, for the first time, I was aiming in the right
direction.
"Aiming
in the right direction," he said, as though he could read my thoughts. “Aiming
with a gun, or with a conjecture slowly evolving into a sound hypothesis.”
"And
who's playing philosopher now?"
For
the first time I believed I was taking the initiative, and a sustained
initiative eventually bears fruit. At least that's what I believed until my
double proved me wrong.
"Where
are we?," I repeated, this time with enough force to make even the
toughest man hesitate.
"In
the same place where Eloísa spent the last three months."
"You
didn't answer my question."
"Yes,
I did. The problem is that you're still a long way from understanding the
answer."
I
wanted to reply, but something stepped between my thoughts. An image. Barely a
flash. Eloísa sitting alone in the Venezia Café. She wasn't reading the
newspaper. She wasn't waiting for anyone. She was looking around. That was what
she was doing. Looking. For weeks I had followed her, convinced she was trying
to conceal clandestine meetings. Yet now, as I rummaged through my memories, I
noticed something strange. Eloísa watched doors. Windows. Mirrors. She watched
passersby. She watched reflections in shop windows. She watched the world the
way someone watches when afraid of being watched. Or when hoping to recognize
something.
"You're
beginning to see it," said my double.
The
rain seemed to have eased. Or perhaps I had simply stopped hearing it, stopped
paying attention to it. If one ceases to perceive something, is that the same
as declaring it nonexistent?
"There's
something else," I murmured.
And
then I remembered. The last time I saw Eloísa alive. The motel. The room. The
window. No. The windows. Before I found the body, before I even opened the
door, I saw Eloísa through the glass. She was standing. Motionless. Looking
out. Looking directly at me. And smiling. It was not the smile of a frightened
woman. It was the smile of someone who, after a long wait, had finally found
what she had been searching for all those months.
"Do
you realize now that Eloísa's smile retrospectively transforms the entire
investigation?"
"No,
I don't realize it," he said.
But
only to disguise the fact that he was beginning to discover the truth, written
in blood on the reverse side of the plot.
"She
no longer looks like a woman being hunted by a jealous gangster. She looks like
someone who was waiting for the narrator to reach precisely this point. She was
lying in wait, watching, waiting; setting a trap or preparing a
revelation."
"Nobody
needs to be murdered to prove they're right..."
I
knew my argument was weak, and my double dispatched it with a few words and a
handful of precise, flawless gestures.
"No.
But some people need to die before someone else begins asking the right
questions."
He
slipped a hand into his raincoat pocket and pulled out something else. It
wasn't a photograph. It was a key. I recognized it immediately. The key to Room
17 at the motel. The same key I had handed to Sergeant Molina that morning. Or
thought I had handed to him.
"Eloísa
wasn't waiting for you," said my double.
I
looked at the key. I looked at the rain. I looked at my own face reflected in
the features of that figure, a stranger, myself.
"She
was waiting for you," he repeated.
And
I understood. Not all at once. Not like a flash of revelation. I understood the
way dawn arrives: slowly, almost reluctantly. Eloísa watched windows, mirrors,
and shopfronts because she was searching for something impossible. Someone
impossible. She had discovered the fissure before I had. The duplication. The
invisible presence. That was why she smiled when she saw me through the glass. She
wasn't recognizing me. She was confusing me. She was confusing us. My double
tossed the key into the water pooled beside the curb.
"Who
killed her?," I asked.
For
the first time, he seemed tired.
"It
does you no good to keep believing that's the important question."
Then
he smiled. It was my smile. The one that appears in photographs when I don't
know I'm being photographed. The genuine one. And then something simple
happened. Something so simple that it took me several seconds to understand it.
The opposite sidewalk was empty. I remained motionless beneath the rain for
several more minutes, an eternity. Then I slipped a hand into my pocket to make
sure the photograph was still there. It wasn't. Of course it wasn't. All I
found was a small black notebook. I opened it cautiously, as though expecting a
scorpion to crawl out from between its pages. On page forty-seven there was a
sentence written in my own hand. A sentence I had no memory of writing.
"If
the encounter with the other ever takes place, ask which of the two of you
started the story." I closed the notebook. The rain kept falling.
Why
should the rain stop in this story?


